The Quebec and Canadian Art Collection is Enriched by Several Significant Drawings (continued)
David Milne (1882-1953), Fifth Avenue Bus, New York (detail), about 1911, gouache, ink and watercolour (?) over traces of graphite, 43.3 x 35.7 cm. MMFA, gift of Roger Fournelle. Photo MMFA, Jean-François Brière
Over the past several months, the Museum has acquired a number of drawings executed by a range of Quebec and Canadian artists from the 19th and 20th centuries. In December 2022, we presented a selection of these works, by Wyatt Eaton and Marc-Aurèle de Foy Suzor-Coté. In this issue, we invite you to discover drawings by Eric Goldberg, Charles William Jefferys, David Milne, Louis Muhlstock and Ernst Neumann.
Eric Goldberg: Selfportrait as a Violinist
Born in Berlin in 1890, Eric Goldberg studied in Paris from 1906 to 1910, initially at the Académie Julian, where he met Canadian artists, including John Lyman, A. Y. Jackson and Randolph Hewton, and then at the École nationale supérieure des beaux-arts. In 1911, he began his studies at the Berlin Academy of Arts, under Lovis Corinth, who freed him from the Academicism of his Parisian instructors. Some years later, in 1928, he moved to Montreal, where he married Regina Seiden, who was also a painter. Goldberg then became a founding member of the Eastern Group and the Contemporary Arts Society.
In Self-portrait as a Violinist, the figure and his instrument cover the sheet of paper from top to bottom. Overlapping and intersecting, a plethora of tight, precise strokes establish volume as well as the interplay of light and shadow, lending the figure a distinct lifelike quality in contrast to the untouched background.
Although characteristic of Western music in general, the choice of the violinist for its subject, which Goldberg renders here in such rare detail, also references the artist’s Jewish heritage.
This drawing is undated. However, given the changes that appeared in Goldberg’s work after his move to the Berlin Academy, we strongly suspect that it was drawn while the artist was studying in Paris, about 1906-1910. To corroborate this theory, we compared it to another one of Goldberg’s self-portraits, drawn about 1911-1914, which clearly reflects Corinth’s Expressionist influence.
Charles William Jefferys: Linemen in Northern Ontario
The job of lineman came about with the advent of the telegraph in Canada, in 1846, and then carried over to the installation of telephone (1870) and electrical (1890) lines. It required exceptional physical skill, because climbing up the wood ties and conductors, to which the lines were attached, demanded excellent coordination and, above all, the ability to work at great heights.
To complete this drawing, Jefferys likely found inspiration in photographs, and the graphic rendering of the ink strokes bears testament to his desire to pull prints from it. In fact, this is a preparatory drawing for The Mines, 1900, the illustration for the month of January in the calendar issued by the Toronto Art League in 1900. The Globe’s art critic wrote of this drawing: “There is originality in his conception of the Mines – men working on the telegraph poles in the front to open communication with the lonely mines on the far hillside.”1
Jefferys would revisit this subject in 1910, in a watercolour titled Linemen of New Ontario. The artist gave our drawing its similar title, Linemen in Northern Ontario, for its showing at the British Empire Exhibition in Wembley, London, in 1925, as specified on the label on the back of the work. The theme of linemen installing a telegraph line in a mountain landscape perfectly captured the spirit of this event, which was organized to promote the British Empire and its industries, and at which Canada was trying to promote itself. The following year, the drawing would tour to three other museums in Great Britain.
David Milne: Fifth Avenue Bus, New York
This work is part of a remarkable group of drawings Milne completed during his last New York period, between 1911 and mid-1916, when he was finding his own style. While there are a few lines in graphite, the composition is mainly made up of juxtaposed marks and lines of colour, used sparingly, on a paper whose surface has been left mostly in reserve.2 Everything is suggested with the greatest simplicity, and several elements are delineated by empty spaces between the coloured-in shapes. In the foreground on the left, we can make out a female form in maroon and brown. The road itself is just a stroke of blue wash, the drippings evident. Some strokes and touches of ochre, brown and green establish the bus. To the right of the image, a building’s facade is rendered in reserve, while to its left, at the height of the “piano nobile” (the noble floor), there is the realistic depiction of the wall of a business, topped with a sign or a free-standing wall covered in signage.
At this stage in his career, Milne was interested in urban New York and, more specifically, in the billboards found there. Figures began to appear in his compositions. The new simplicity of his style, which would become characteristic of his work, was influenced by Cézanne’s first North American exhibition – twenty watercolours that were presented in March 1911 at Alfred Stieglitz’s gallery 291. Milne also owed his inspiration to American painter John Marin, to whom critic Clement Greenberg compared him. In about 1912, Milne completed a painting titled Gray Billboards,3 inspired by our drawing. The changes in this second composition include the addition of another billboard beneath the 1911 one, which has itself been raised, attesting yet again to his interest in the subject. The reserves are dispensed with, only to be replaced by paint strokes in various shades of white.
Louis Muhlstock: The Homeless
This three-quarter portrait depicts a middle-aged man whose face has been lined by a life of hard knocks. In the tight frame, his hunched shoulders are covered by a shapeless garment or blanket. The smooth swathes of this clothing mirror the uniform background of the composition. The figure’s mostly bare forehead illuminates the scene. Meanwhile, his thinning hair encircling his scalp, and the scruffiness of his beard, moustache and eyebrows, serve to create contrast. Thin black lines mark the contours of his right ear, nose and eyes. The homeless man’s amused expression is highlighted by the wrinkles on his face. In 1925, during his first Montreal exhibition, at the Spring Salon of the Art Association of Montreal (AAM), now the Montreal Museum of Fine Arts, Muhlstock presented two charcoal drawings, including the portrait of a blind man. A decade later, he exhibited more portraits, among which might have been our drawing, The Homeless. As a critic from the Montreal Star wrote: “The drawings are all of interest either as good drawings or as studies of character, and most of them are portrait heads or, in a few cases, only faces,” adding, “Mr. Muhlstock is at his best when he has character as well as form to put into his drawings.”4
Muhlstock’s work is characterized by recurring themes emblematic of life in urban Montreal. In 1931, when the artist returned from Paris, he observed that the economic crisis had made the neighbourhood where he lived on Saint-Dominique Street, in the heart of the working-class Jewish quarter, poorer than ever. The subjects that interested him were in keeping with the social activism exercised by the members of this community. His models were the homeless, the jobless, the factory workers and the immigrants, rendered with the greatest care and sensitivity. Muhlstock elevates them from the everyday, imbuing them with a certain dignity. What he achieves through his work is a record of the human condition, always returning to the pencil to execute a new drawing, and rendering the touchingly invisible visible. The same can be observed in the painting titled Leduc Lane, Montreal, which was featured in a previous issue of the M Webzine and is currently on display in the Claire and Marc Bourgie Pavilion.
Ernst Neumann: Study of a Head (Max Neumann, the Artist’s Father)
This graphite portrait was completed in 1927. Ernst Neumann was just twenty years old when he was a student at the AAM. At the time, he was also studying with Edwin Holgate, a master of portrait and print. The drawing was exhibited the following year at the AAM’s 45th Spring Salon, but it was not for sale. It is likely the artist wanted to keep this portrait of his father, Max Neumann, for himself. The inscription of the address on the back of the work (757 Bloomfield Ave., in Outremont) suggests that Ernst Neumann was still living at home with his father when it was drawn. The subject’s features are also outlined and marked by age; the wrinkles on his cheeks are clearly visible and his hairline is receding, leaving the forehead bare. The man seems to be deep in thought, with his eyes half-closed and his face tilted downwards.
Throughout his career, Neumann dedicated a major portion of his practice to drawing. However, pride of place was given to the art of printmaking, which was what he was known for. Despite the fact that portraiture was clearly important to him, those he produced remain little known and are poorly inventoried. Still, Study of a Head (Max Neumann, the Artist’s Father) ably demonstrates the artist’s talent as a draftsperson, and displays the virtuosity and sensitivity that characterize his best-known prints. A few years following the completion of this drawing, about 1931-1932, Neumann would also complete a wood engraving titled The Artist’s Father.
1 Lynn C. Doyle, “Art Students’ League,” The Globe (Toronto), December 27, 1899.
2 The “reserves” are the sections of the drawing that have not been covered with pictorial materials, thus leaving the base paper visible.
3 David Milne Jr. and David P. Silcox, David B. Milne. Catalogue raisonné of the Paintings, vol. 1 (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1998), p. 68, cat. 104.6 (colour pl. 4).
4 “Drawings by Louis Muhlstock,” The Montreal Star, November 25, 1935.